Roof Repair vs Replacement How to Make the Decision

As a commercial business owner, ensuring your property is secure is essential to the smooth running of your operations. Unfortunately, natural disasters like storms can cause significant damage to your building, including your roof. Knowing whether to repair or replace a damaged roof can be challenging, and making the right decision is critical. However, with a roof inspection from the experts, you can gain helpful knowledge into the right decision for your business.In this blog post, our team at Roofing USA will outline the key factors to consider when deciding whether to repair or replace a commercial roof post-storm damage.

Assessing the Extent of Damage to Your Roof

First, it’s important to assess the extent of damage caused by the storm. Minor damages like a small leak can usually be repaired without requiring a full roof replacement. However, if the storm has led to extensive water leakage and structural damage, or if more than 30% of the roof is damaged, then a complete replacement may be necessary. Involve a professional roofing contractor in this assessment process, as they can provide an accurate estimate of the damage and recommend the best course of action.

Evaluating the Roof’s Age and Lifespan

When considering whether to replace orrepair your storm-damaged roof, it’s important to factor in the age and remaining lifespan of the roof. If your commercial roof was already nearing the end of its expected lifespan before the storm, opting for a replacement may prove more advantageous than a repair. This is because a repair would only provide a temporary extension of its lifespan, and inevitably, a replacement would still be necessary. By choosing to replace the roof, you ensure a longer-term solution and avoid the need for additional repairs shortly, saving you time and money. Additionally, a new roof can enhance the overall aesthetics of your property and potentially increase its value. Consider consulting with a professional roofing contractor to assess the condition of your roof and make an informed decision that aligns with your long-term goals and budget.

Structural Concerns Post-Storm

Promptly identify any potential structural compromises caused by storm damage to the entireroof system . When there are visible signs indicating structural weaknesses or damage, simply repairing the surface damage might not suffice. In such instances, considering the replacement of the entire roof becomes imperative to guarantee the safety and integrity of your building for years to come. By addressing these issues proactively, you ensure that your property is fortified against future storms and inclement weather conditions. The installation of a new roof will enhance the durability and resilience of your building and provide added protection and peace of mind. With a robust and reliable roof in place, you can rest assured knowing that your property is safeguarded from potential leaks, water damage, and other structural issues that can arise over time. Investing in a new roof is an investment in the long-term well-being of your property. It is a proactive measure that can prevent costly repairs and potential hazards.

Repair Speed vs. Replacement Duration

In addition to carefully weighing the technical considerations of repair versus replacement, it is crucial to take into account the potential business implications associated with differing timeframes. Roof repair usually involves patching up damaged areas, replacing a few shingles, or fixing leaks, procedures that can be completed relatively quickly with minimal disruption. Roof replacement, however, is a much more extensive process. It involves removing the existing roof, addressing any underlying structural issues, and installing a completely new roofing system. This process can take significantly more time, potentially spanning several weeks depending on the size of the roof and the extent of the damage. This longer duration could disrupt your business operations, as sections of your property may be inaccessible during the replacement. Therefore, it is essential to plan appropriately for the potential business interruptions that a roof replacement may necessitate, ensuring minimal impact on your day-to-day operations. While opting for a roof replacement may require a longer duration compared to a simple repair, it presents a unique opportunity to install a brand-new, cutting-edge, and highly energy-efficient or durable roofing material. This upgrade not only enhances the overall performance and longevity of the roof but also contributes to greater cost savings and environmental sustainability in the long run. It is essential to carefully evaluate these factors and make an informed decision that aligns with both your immediate and long-term objectives.


Cost Considerations

The financial aspect is undoubtedly a significant factor to consider when deciding between the repair and replacement of a storm-damaged roof. Initially, repairing may seem like the more economical choice as it requires fewer materials and labor. However, if the damage is extensive or the roof is nearing the end of its lifespan, frequent repairs might prove to be more costly in the long run. On the other hand, roof replacement presents a larger upfront cost, but it can be a more cost-effective solution over time. A new roof reduces the need for ongoing maintenance and repairs, offers improved energy efficiency, and increases the value of your property. Additionally, many new roofs come with warranties that can provide additional financial protection.

Roofing Types and Their Repair/Replace Dynamics

When repairing or replacing commercial roofing materials, carefully consider the unique characteristics of each type.

TPO and EPDM roofing

Thermoplastic Olefin (TPO) andEthylene Propylene Diene Monomer (EPDM) are popular choices for commercial roofing due to their durability and cost-effectiveness. In the case of minor damage, both materials can be patched, making repairs a feasible option. TPO roofing, known for its heat-reflective and energy-efficient properties, can often be repaired by heat-welding a new piece of membrane over the damaged area. However, the repairability of TPO roofs can decrease over time due to weathering and exposure to UV rays. On the other hand, EPDM, known for its superior durability and lifespan, can be repaired using specific primer and tape. But, similar to TPO roofing, the repairability of EPDM roofing decreases with age and weathering. If your TPO or EPDM roof has suffered extensive damage or is nearing the end of its lifespan, a complete replacement could be the more cost-effective solution in the long term. A professional roofing contractor can guide you in making the right decision based on the age and condition of your roof.

Metal Roofing

Metal roofs are a high-durability option known for their fire resistance, longevity, and exceptional weather resistance. Damage to these roofs often manifests as dents, punctures, or corrosion, depending on the type of metal used and the storm severity. Often, isolated damage can be addressed by replacing individual panels or applying sealants to minor leaks, which makes repairs a cost-effective route for minor to moderate damage. However, if the roof has significant rust, or corrosion, or if large sections are damaged, a complete replacement might be the best option. Moreover, an old metal roof nearing the end of its life expectancy might be better replaced than repaired. Consulting with a professional roofing contractor can help determine the best course of action based on your roof’s specific condition and needs.

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are one of the most commonly used roofing materials due to their affordability and ease of installation. However, they tend to be less durable compared to other materials. If your asphalt shingle roof has minor damage such as a few missing or cracked shingles, repair might be the most cost-effective option. However, if the roof has aged or if the damage is extensive, replacement would be the better option.

Tile Roofing

Tile roofing, on the other hand, is known for its durability and longevity. If properly maintained, they can last for several decades. In many cases, tile roofing can often be repaired rather than replaced, even after a storm.However, if the underlayment—the layer beneath the tiles—is damaged, a full roof replacement might be necessary.

Flat Roofing

Flat roofs, often seen on commercial buildings, have unique needs when it comes to repair and replacement. Flat roofs are more prone to water pooling and leakage, so the presence of extensive water damage after a storm often necessitates a full replacement. Conversely, small punctures or cracks can typically be repaired quickly and easily.


Receive a Worry-Free Roof Inspection From Roofing USA

The decision to repair or replace your commercial roof after storm damage can be complex, balancing many factors such as the extent of damage, the roof’s age, the type of roofing material, financial considerations, and the potential impact on your business operations. It’s critical not to rush this decision, but rather, engage with an experienced professional who can provide accurate assessments and recommendations.We are the best roofing company Charleston, SC offers and we understand that your commercial property is a significant investment, and its protection is our utmost priority. Our experienced team of licensed professionals can assist in making this crucial decision of repair versus replacement after storm damage. We offer comprehensive roof inspections, where we assess the state of your roof to identify any potential damage or weaknesses. Our experts are skilled in working with various roofing materials, allowing us to provide repairs or replacement services tailored to your specific roof type and needs. We also offer transparent, upfront pricing, ensuring you are well-informed about the costs involved.With Roofing USA, you can expect reliable, high-quality roofing solutions that stand the test of time. For more information about our roofing services, contact us today!

Copyright 2023 © All Rights Reserved. Roofing USA | Privacy Policy

Roofing USA is committed to ensuring that it’s website is accessible to people with disabilities. All the pages on our website will meet W3C WAI’s Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 2.0, Level A conformance. Any issues should be reported to

Skip to content